Pet-Friendly Milkshakes for Dogs and Cats

Pet-Friendly Milkshakes for Dogs and Cats

Humans have been enjoying creamy, indulgent milkshakes for decades. But why should we have all the fun? Now your dog or cat can enjoy a shake of their own, crafted with fresh, wholesome ingredients made just for them. We don’t recommend human milkshakes for pets, but pet-friendly milkshakes aren’t just OK — they’re a delicious, nutrient-rich treat for your animal companion. Of course, you should always consult with your veterinarian before making changes to your pet’s diet, especially if your pet has any health conditions or special dietary needs. Let's get started!

 

The Essential Pet-Friendly Milkshake Recipe

Ingredients

  • 2 parts Fresh Toppers or plain Greek yogurt

  • 1 part Dehydrated Goat Milk, rehydrated

  • Pet-friendly whipped cream (optional)

  • Garnishes of your choice (optional)

Directions

  1. Mix ½ tablespoon of goat milk powder with ¼ cup warm water and stir continuously until fully dissolved.
  2. Combine 1 part rehydrated goat milk powder with 2 parts Fresh Toppers or plain Greek yogurt and blend.
  3. Pour into a sundae cup.
  4. Top with pet-friendly whipped cream.
  5. Garnish with your choice of toppings and serve!

Primal’s Fresh Toppers add a boost of whole-food nutrition, while our Dehydrated Goat Milk for cats and dogs contains probiotics for digestive and immune support. The best part? This recipe is versatile, so your pet can enjoy a unique and delicious treat each and every time! 

 

Get Creative with These Pet-Friendly Milkshake Recipes 

There are dozens of ways to mix and match your pet’s favorite flavors to concoct the perfect tasty and nutritious milkshake. These pet-friendly milkshake recipes are easy to make at home and completely customizable based on your dog’s or cat’s preferences. Shake things up with flavored Frozen Raw Goat Milk, toppers, and treats. Here are a few of our top pet-friendly milkshake recipes to get you started.

Flavored Milkshakes for Dogs & Cats

Dogs and cats with picky palates will love the classic flavors in these milkshakes and enjoy a boost of whole-food nutrition:

Sit, Stay, and Shake: Milkshake Recipes for Dogs

Here’s how to make a few of our favorite dog-friendly milkshakes, designed with the discerning canine palate in mind:

 

Best Garnishes for Pet-Friendly Milkshakes

In addition to topping off your pet-friendly milkshake with Primal’s freeze-dried or dehydrated treats, you can sprinkle on one or a few tasty garnishes to delight your dog or cat. These pet-safe additions bring fun textures, fresh flavors, and even more nutrition to make snack time extra special.

Fruits & Vegetables for Dogs & Cats

Fresh fruits and vegetables make flavorful and nutritious garnishes for a pet-friendly milkshake. These additions provide natural fiber, vitamins, and even a touch of sweetness or crunch your dog or cat will love. You can serve them fresh, puréed, or even frozen for a treat that beats the heat!


Dog-Safe Fruits & Veggies

Try one of these fruits or vegetables that are safe for dogs in small, pet-approved portions:

  • Apple slices (no seeds)

  • Berries

  • Banana slices

  • Peach slices (no pit)

  • Shredded raw carrots

  • Cucumber slices

  • Green beans

Safe Fruits & Vegetables for Cats

Top your cat’s milkshake with one of these feline-approved fruit and vegetables, served pureed or in tiny, bite-size pieces:

  • Cantaloupe

  • Watermelon (no seeds or rind)

  • Strawberries

  • Banana slices

  • Carrots (steamed)

  • Peas (cooked or mashed)

Fruits To Avoid

Be aware that some fruits aren’t safe for pets to eat. Avoid feeding your dog or cat:

  • Grapes and raisins (toxic to dogs and cats)

  • Citrus fruits, including lemons, limes, and oranges (too acidic)

  • Canned fruits (often high in sugar and additives)

Dog-Friendly Whipped Cream

Whipped cream can be a fun and tasty treat for dogs — in moderation. The best dog-friendly whipped cream is plain, unsweetened, and free from added sugars or artificial sweeteners. If buying store-bought options, always check the label and avoid whipped cream made with xylitol, which is toxic to dogs even in small amounts.

Making your own whipped cream at home is simple and lets you control exactly what goes into your pet’s treat. Here are a few safe and tasty bases to try:

  • Coconut Cream: Chill a can of full-fat coconut milk, scoop out the solidified cream, and whip it with a whisk or electric mixer until thick and fluffy.

  • Oat or Almond Milk: For dogs with dairy sensitivities, use plain, unsweetened oat or almond milk without xylitol or other artificial additives. Chill, then whip it like dairy cream. 

  • Dehydrated Goat Milk: Primal’s Dehydrated Goat Milk makes a nutritious base for pet-friendly whipped cream. Rehydrate and then chill and whip until frothy for a rich topping that complements your dog’s milkshake.

Can Cats Have Whipped Cream?

Cats can enjoy a whipped treat, too, but with caution. Homemade goat milk whipped cream is the best option. Avoid whipped cream made with cow’s milk, which is high in sugar and lactose and offers little nutritional value for cats. It may also cause digestive upset or weight gain.

Xylitol-Free Peanut Butter for Pets

Peanut butter is a classic canine favorite and a great way to add creamy richness to your dog’s milkshake. Just be sure to use xylitol-free peanut butter with no added sugars or artificial sweeteners. In small amounts, it’s a tasty source of protein and healthy fat that most dogs adore.

Best to leave this topping for the dogs, though: Peanut butter isn’t recommended for cats. It’s high in fat and calories, provides no real nutritional benefit for felines, and can lead to digestive upset. Looking for another feline-friendly treat? Bone Broth catsicles are cooling, hydrating, and super nutritious.

 

Mix Up Your Pet-Friendly Milkshake With Primal Pet Foods

Which combination will be your pet’s favorite? Which Primal treats would they choose to top off their milkshake? There’s really only one way to find out! Start mixing, matching, and serving up delicious, pet-friendly milkshakes packed with Primal raw nutrition your pet will love! 

Back to blog

Shop Related Products